Karl Vaters: Are Pastors Responsible for the Outcomes of Church Health and Growth?

Image: Ben White | Unsplash

Who is responsible for the health and growth of a local church?

Is it all up to the pastoral leadership? As one former megachurch pastor used to say, “if it’s going to be, it’s up to me.”

Or is it all up to Jesus who said “I will build my church”?

Obviously, the ultimate growth of the church is in Jesus’ hands, but he’s given church leaders certain responsibilities for our local congregation.

So, while we should never take on a burden that isn’t ours, we also need to be careful not to act as if we have no responsibility for outcomes at all. If leadership means anything, it has to include that.

What Are We Responsible For?

Take a look at the instructions for church leaders (pastors, apostles, teachers, deacons, presbyters, and so on) in the New Testament.

There are passages about

  • Moral purity
  • Caring for the church
  • Reaching the lost
  • Discipling believers
  • Raising leaders
  • Theological integrity
  • Family life
  • Generosity
  • Accountability
  • Financial stewardship
  • Church unity
  • And more

But there’s one thing missing.

With all the instructions church leaders are given, there’s not a single instruction about getting our attendance numbers up.

Not a word about breaking growth barriers.

Not one verse linking the value of a church to the number of people attending it.

Not even a suggestion that if a church isn’t growing numerically we’re doing something wrong.

The Tasks We’ve Been Given

Throughout the New Testament, we can find numerous detailed instructions for how to help a church be healthy, effective, loving and prayerful, but nothing about how to be bigger this year than we were last year.

So maybe we should take our cue from that.

As church leaders, we are responsible for the tasks we have been given, but not for tasks we have not been given. And we have not been given the task of causing the numerical growth of a local congregation.

But that does not absolve us of bearing any responsibility for outcomes.

Measuring The Immeasurable

For instance, in what I call the Pastoral Prime Mandate of Ephesians 4:11-13, church leaders are not just given an instruction to “equip his people for works of service,” the rest of the sentence gives us an outcome to aim for. Namely, “so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ.”

Click here to read more.
Source: Christianity Today