“Ben-Hur” Bombs at Box Office With $11M Opening

Jack Huston plays Judah Ben-Hur in Ben-Hur from Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures and Paramount Pictures.
Jack Huston plays Judah Ben-Hur in Ben-Hur from Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures and Paramount Pictures.

With an estimated production cost that’s in the vicinity of $100M, MGM and Paramount certainly didn’t build Ben-Hur to fail this weekend.

But if there’s one Come-to-Jesus from this remake’s estimated disastrous $11M opening: It’s still a challenge for Hollywood to cross over a faith-based film to the masses 12 years after the $370M ($612M global) success of Mel Gibson’s The Passion of the Christ.

Ben-Hur is the third big-budget faith-based movie from a major studio to fall from box office grace in the wake of Noah ($101.2M domestic B.O., $125M production cost) and the mighty Moses misfire Exodus: Gods and Kings ($65M domestic B.O., $140M cost).

The irony? Last year at about this time, Sony’s thrifty-priced, holy-roller titleWar Room made $11.3M at 1,135 venues; 63% less Ben-Hur’s 3,084 theater count.Ben-Hur‘s opening isn’t that far from where Sony’s low-budget Roman Centurion epic Risen opened on Feb. 19 with $11.8M at 2,915 locations. Ben-Hur will need to rely on the kindness of such Christian offshore territories as Latin America to raise it up, out of its red sea of ink; and that’s not an unforeseeable miracle given how these sword and sandal movies can make two-to-four times their domestic take abroad. MGM carries the bulk of Ben-Hur‘s production cross at 80%, while Paramount is only on the hook for 20%.

In all fairness, the marketplace is stacked against all titles, not just Ben-Hur, due to schools back in session the final weekend of the Rio Summer Olympics. Suicide Squad is back up at its original projection this morning with $20.2M (-54%) in No. 1. Sausage Party is down -54% with $15.7M in second. That’s fine,  but a tad lower than we heard for this Sony/Annapurna title.  Warner Bros.’ Todd Phillips action comedy War Dogs is looking at an OK $14.8M (B CinemaScore), and then there’s Kubo and the Two Strings which is the lowest debut of the four Laika/Focus movies with an estimated $12.1M (A CinemaScore).

But just like the faith-based measured Paramount’s Noah against the Bible two years ago, leading to its ultimate alienation of that audience and short legs at the box office, Ben-Hur is being compared by reviewers (31% Rotten Tomatoes score) and moviegoers to the 1959 multi-Oscar winning movie. That’s one of the primary factors that’s curbing Ben-Hur‘s weekend business. Also, fresh face leading man Jack Huston isn’t turning turnstiles in the way that Emma Watson’s social wattage, and Russell Crowe star did for Noah ($43.7M opening). And of course, the sword and sandal genre has yellowed since the early aughts when Gladiator and Troy ruled.

In addition, per our discussions with faith-based marketing insiders, there’s a division as to whether team MGM/Paramount fully swayed the flocks to Ben-Hur in their outreach. One thing is for sure: Both studios sold this to the faith-based and the fruits of their labors can be seen in Ben-Hur’s A- CinemaScore, the same grade that Risenreceived. Women showed up at 51%, 94% over 25 (over 50 was 46%). Whenever we see CinemaScores that high for a film like Ben-Hur, and audience breakdowns like that, it’s a good indication that the faithful showed up, as they typically hand out favorable grades for Biblical and Christian-themed movies.  And there are A-, As and an A+ (those under 18 at 1%) spread throughout. On PostTrak, Ben-Hur received a blase 77% postive score (3.5 out of 5 stars), indicating that the secular crowd may have weighed in, given its 48% definite recommend. Also, per PostTrak, Ben-Hur drew 63% men; 87% over 25. Risen fared a bit better with 81% positive score, a 66% definite recommend, and there was evidence that the Faithful turned up to that Joseph Fiennes movie as indicated by its older women turnout (54% women, 87% over 25).

Click here to read more.

SOURCE: Deadline