Demetria Lucas D’Oyley of The Root Asks Did the New York Daily News Go Too Far in Posting Picture of Alton Sterling’s Gruesome Death?

Portion of New York Daily News cover image PHOTO ILLUSTRATION
Portion of New York Daily News cover image

On Thursday, the New York Daily News published on its cover a graphic image of the slain body of Alton Sterling, who was killed by a Baton Rouge, La., police officer Tuesday night.

The image was a screenshot from one of two widely circulating cellphone videos of Sterling’s demise, the result of multiple shots fired into his body.

The photo of Sterling’s body was haunting, disturbing and, for many, triggering. Across social media, many people expressed outrage, saying the image reminded them of a lynching postcard and that it was insensitive to Sterling’s family and friends to show his body so soon. Others pointed out that white bodies are never displayed in the media this way and that the Daily News had gone too far.

These arguments aren’t inaccurate. The repeated murders of black people do seem like modern-day lynchings. And yes, if I were Sterling’s mom or loved one, I wouldn’t want to see the body of my loved one plastered on a newspaper for people to gawk at. And no, white bodies are not often shown this way. Five white police officers were killed Thursday night in Dallas, allegedly by a lone shooter. I’m pretty sure their bodies won’t be on the cover of any newspapers.

Still, while acknowledging the legitimacy of those arguments, I support, applaud even, the Daily News for making Sterling’s tragic death front and center on Thursday’s cover. Yes, it was a decision made to sell papers, as is the purpose of any publication. But it also served to put the tragic encounters between black people and police officers right in the face of their readers, which is much needed.

Images hold power. “The world seldom believes the horror stories of history until they are documented via the mass media,” Martin Luther King Jr. once said, responding to the role of photographers in the civil rights movement. The power of imagery is why legendary photographer Gordon Parks thought that a camera served as a “weapon” against racism. The power of an image is what compelled Mamie Till, mother of 14-year-old Emmett, to have an open casket at her son’s funeral, showcasing his battered, bloated body so the world could “see what they did to my baby.” The photos of Emmett’s body ran in Jet magazine and the Chicago Defender and the outrage over his gruesome death in 1955 helped to inspire the civil rights movement.

The Daily News’ intent (once again, in addition to selling papers) seemed to be an effort to fall on the right side of history and inspire moral outrage. It forced readers and passers-by, to really see what’s going on. See, in New York, the Daily News is everywhere. When you walk in the bodega to buy your morning coffee, it’s right there in your face. As you walk to the train or to your office, you’ll pass the cover hanging from newsstands. The paper is unavoidable. And that cover story is unavoidable. Sterling’s death is unavoidable.

Readers of sites like The Root may not need a newspaper cover to inform them about police killings of black people, and it’s likely all their friends, family and favorite celebrities are discussing it. But that’s not the case for everyone. How many people showed up to work Wednesday or Thursday, and no one mentioned Sterling or Philando Castile? How many of your nonblack Facebook friends are practicing privileged indifference, carrying on like business as usual without a peep about the string of black deaths this week?

Click here to read more