Pope Criticizes Marxism Ahead of Visit to Cuba

CubaCuba will listen with respect to Pope
Benedict XVI during his visit next week even if he differs with island
leaders, the country’s foreign minister said Friday after the pontiff
described Marxism as out of step with the times.

Pictured: A
woman uses a public phone next to images of Cuba’s leader Fidel Castro,
left, and Pope Benedict XVI in Havana, Cuba, Friday March 23, 2012.
(AP Photo/Javier Galeano)

Benedict made the
comment to reporters during his long flight to Mexico, the first stop in
his six-day tour. While it was in keeping with the Vatican’s position,
it was an unexpectedly blunt statement to come just days before he will
be on Cuban soil.

Foreign Minister Bruno Rodriguez avoided any clash over the statement.

consider the exchange of ideas to be useful. Our people have deep
convictions developed over the course of our history,” Rodriguez said at
a news conference. “Cuba will listen with all respect to his holiness.”

He added that the Cuban system “is a democratic social project, genuinely chosen, which is constantly perfecting itself.”

said it is “evident that Marxist ideology as it was conceived no longer
responds to reality,” and exhorted Cubans to “find new models, with
patience, and in a constructive way.”

about reports of harassment and detention of dissidents on the island,
Benedict said the church wants “to help in the spirit of dialogue to
avoid trauma and to help bring about a just and fraternal society.”

comments were as bold as any his predecessor, John Paul II, made during
his historic 1998 tour of Cuba. But they stopped short of directly
challenging the country’s single-party political model, which has been
in place for five decades. Benedict arrives Monday in the eastern city
of Santiago de Cuba.

Robert A. Pastor, a
professor of international relations at American University and former
national security adviser for Latin America during the Carter
administration, said Benedict’s words seemed calculated to initiate a
dialogue about political change while giving the Cubans space to
maneuver by underscoring the importance of gradualism.

placed himself on the side of freedom, but not necessarily in a manner
that would put the Cuban regime on the defensive,” Pastor said. “They
will not be excited by this. They won’t be happy with it. But I think
they have to be realistic enough to understand that the pope could say
nothing less.”

President Raul Castro has
initiated a slate of economic reforms in recent years permitting more
private-sector activity on the communist-run island where the state has
long controlled nearly the entire economy.

Cubans have opened small businesses and are farming previously
state-held land. It is now legal for all islanders to buy and sell homes
and cars.

Benedict made even stronger remarks during his first visit to Latin America, a 2007 trip to Brazil.

Marxist system, where it found its way into government, not only left a
sad heritage of economic and ecological destruction, but also a painful
destruction of the human spirit,” the pope said then.

He has also been critical of unrestrained capitalism and globalization.

emphasized areas of common ground between Havana and the Vatican, such
as opposition to “the oppression of finances, opposition to treatment of
human beings as if they were animals of consumption.”

most important message to get from this exchange is that it’s good that
the pope is going,” Pastor said. “And it’s good that he’s doing so in a
manner that gives the Cuban regime some room to change instead of be

Reaction to Benedict’s comments in South Florida, where some Cuban-Americans have criticized the pontiff’s trip, was mixed.

very optimistic that the Pope’s words and actions will have a great
impact on the Cuban people that will lead to political change,” said
Andy S. Gomez, a senior fellow at the University at Miami’s Institute
for Cuban & Cuban-American Studies, who is traveling to Cuba as part
of a church delegation. Gomez came from Cuba to the U.S. in 1954 at age

Former U.S. Rep. Lincoln Diaz-Balart, a
Cuban-American and staunch opponent of the Cuban government, said he
would reserve judgment about the pope’s visit for now, but criticized
the role of the Roman Catholic Church has played in Cuba. Last week,
Havana Cardinal Jaime Ortega asked state security to remove 13
dissidents from a church they had occupied to press Benedict to raise
their complaints with the Cuban government.

said the pope should meet with representatives of the island’s small
but vocal dissident community – something that Benedict does not plan to

“This pope is not visiting the Cuba that
John Paul II visited,” Diaz-Balart said. “There’s much more opposition.
There’s a new generation of leadership, a new generation of leaders in
every municipality of Cuba, and they have to be acknowledged.”

officials said 797 journalists from 295 media outlets in 33 nations
were issued visas to cover the 84-year-old pope’s visit, which is to
include a meeting with Raul and possibly Fidel Castro.

Associated Press writers Andrea Rodriguez in Havana and Laura Wides-Munoz in Miami contributed to this report.

Follow Peter Orsi on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/Peter(underscore)Orsi .